The neurological dysfunction associated with the vertebral
subluxation may take many forms. A previous column discussed nerve compression physiology.
This month, I will address the production of aberrant afferent input to the CNS as a
result of vertebral subluxation.
The intervertebral motion segment is richly endowed by nociceptive and mechanoreceptive
structures. As a consequence, biomechanical dysfunction may result in an alteration in
normal nociception and/or mechanoreception. Aberrated afferent input to the CNS may lead
to dysponesis. To use the contemporary jargon of the computer industry, "garbage in
-- garbage out."
Appreciation of these processes begins with an understanding of the neuroanatomy of the
tissues of the intervertebral motion segment.
Several papers have described the innervation of human cervical and lumbar
intervertebral discs.
Bogduk et al observed that the lumbar intervertebral discs are supplied by a variety of
nerves.
The sinuvertebral nerve supplies the posterior aspect of the disc and the posterior
longitudinal ligament. The posterolateral aspects are innervated by adjacent ventral
primary rami and from the grey rami communicantes. The lateral aspects of the disc are
innervated by the rami communicantes. The anterior longitudinal ligament is innervated by
recurrent branches of rami communicantes. [1]
Clinically, Bogduk stated that intervertebral discs can be a source of pain without
rupture or herniation. Torsional stress may result in circumferential tears in the
innervated outer third of the annulus. Compression injuries may lead to internal
disruption of the disc, resulting in mechanical or chemical stimulation of the nerve
endings in the annulus. [2]
Bogduk et al also examined the nerve supply to the cervical intervertebral discs. The
sinuvertebral nerves were found to supply the disc at their level of entry as well as the
disc above. Nerve fibers were found as deeply as the outer third of the annulus. [3]
Mendel et al stated that nerves were seen throughout the annulus. In addition,
receptors resembling Pacinian corpuscles and Golgi tendon organs were seen in the
posterolateral region of the disc. The authors conclude that human cervical intervertebral
discs are supplied with both nerve fibers and mechanoreceptors. [4]
Human cervical facet joints are also equipped with mechanoreceptors. McLain found Type
I, Type II, and Type III mechanoreceptors, as well as unencapsulated nerve endings in the
cervical discs of normal subjects.
The author stated, "The presence of mechanoreceptive and nociceptive nerve endings
in cervical facet capsules proves that these tissues are monitored by the central nervous
system and implies that neural input from the facets is important to proprioception and
pain sensation in the cervical spine. Previous studies have suggested that protection
muscular reflexes modulated by these types of mechanoreceptors are important in preventing
joint instability and degeneration." [5]
Wyke has described articular mechanoreceptors, and explored the clinical implications
of dysafferentation in pain perception. [6,7]
Besides the discs and articular capsules, mechanoreceptors and other neural tissues
have been described in the ligaments attached to the spine.
Jiang et al noted that Pacinian corpuscles were scattered randomly, close to blood
vessels, whereas Ruffini corpuscles were seen in the periphery of human supraspinal and
interspinal ligaments. [8]
Rhalmi et al found nerve fibers in the ligamentum flavum, the supraspinal ligament, and
the lumbodorsal fascia. [9]
The authors of the remarkable book "Segmental Neuropathy," published by
Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College, proposed the concept of a "neural
image," dependent upon the integrity of neural receptors and afferent pathways. If
afferent input is compromised, efferent response may be qualitatively and quantitatively
compromised. [10]
Alterations in mechanoreceptor function may affect postural tone.
Murphy summarized the neurological pathways associated with the maintenance of
background postural tone: "Weight bearing disc and mechanoreceptor functional
integrity regulates and drives background postural neurologic information and function
(muscular) through the unconscious mechanoreception anterior and posterior spinocerebellar
tract, cerebellum, vestibular nuclei, descending medial longitudinal fasciculus (medial
and lateral vestibulospinal tracts), regulatory anterior horn cell pathway." [11]
The anterior horn cells provide motor output which travels via motor nerves to muscle
fibers. Although stimulation of articular mechanoreceptors may exert an analgesic effect,
use of manipulation for the episodic, symptomatic treatment of pain is not chiropractic.
Correcting the specific vertebral subluxation cause is paramount to restoring normal
afferent input to the CNS, and allowing the body to correctly perceive itself and its
environment.
References
1. Bogduk N, Tynan W, Wilson AS: "The nerve supply to the human lumbar
intervertebral discs." J Anat (1981 Jan) 132(Pt 1):39.
2. Bogduk N: "Pathology of lumbar disc pain." Manual Medicine (1990) 5(2):72.
3. Bogduk N, Winsor M, Inglis A: "The innervation of the cervical intervertebral
discs." Spine (1988 Jan) 13(1):2.
4. Mendel T, Wink CS, Zimny ML: "Neural elements in human cervical intervertebral
discs." Spine (1992 Feb) 17(2):132.
5. McLain RF: "Mechanoreceptor endings in human cervical facet joints." Spine
(1994 Mar 1) 19(5):495.
6. Wyke B: "The neurology of joints. Ann R Coll Surg (Br) (1967):25.
7. Wyke B: "Neurology of the cervical spinal joints." Physiother
(1979) 65:72.
8. Jiang H, Russell G, Raso VJ et al: "The nature and distribution of the
innervation of human supraspinal and interspinal ligaments." Spine (1995 Apr
15) 20(8):869.
9. Rhalmi S, Yahia LH, Newman N, Isler M: "Immunohistochemical study of nerves in
lumbar spine ligaments." Spine (1993 Feb) 18(2):264.
10. "Segmental Neuropathy." Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College. Toronto,
Ontario. No date.
11. Murphy DJ: "Neurogenic posture." Am J of Clinical Chiropractic
(1995) 5(1):16.
(Dr. Christopher Kent, president of the Council on Chiropractic Practice, is a 1973
graduate of Palmer College of Chiropractic. Named "Chiropractic Researcher of the
Year" in 1991 by the ICA and in 1994 by the WCA, Dr. Kent is director of research for
EMG Consultants, Inc., and co-founder of Paradigm Partners, Inc. With Dr. Patrick
Gentempo, Jr., Dr. Kent produces a monthly audio tape journal, "On Purpose,"
covering current events in science, philosophy, and politics of vital interest to the
practicing chiropractor. For subscription information call 1-800-892-6463.)