The following article was first distributed in the Journal of
Vertebral Subluxation Research (JVSR) Research Update, May 2, 2001. To
receive research updates or to learn more about JVSR, visit www.jvsr.com.
by Matthew McCoy, D.C., editor, Journal of Vertebral Subluxation
Research
Self-proclaimed "quackbuster" Dr. Stephen Barrett is getting
media attention again and he wastes no time taking a stab at the
chiropractic profession:
"Chiropractors too have felt Barrett's sting. While he sees
benefits in chiropractic manipulation, he wonders about 'a whole
profession based on an idea -- subluxations -- that isn't true.'"
This absurd quote can be found in Leon Jaroff's article titled:
"The Man Who Loves to Bust Quacks" in the April 30, 2001 issue
of Time magazine.
The article portrays Barrett as a hero, promotes his website (http://www.quackwatch.com)
and contains this quote as well: "Twenty years ago, I had trouble
getting my ideas through to the media, today I am the media."
We know the extent of Barrett's ignorance from the statement regarding
subluxations and with the "I am the media" quote we now have
some insight into the size of Barrett's ego.
Keep in mind that Barrett is on the Editorial Board of The
Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine and is a long time
collaborator of Sam Homola. (http://www.jvsr.com/abstracts/nl_20010402.htm)
Prometheus Books, which publishes the alternative medicine journal,
also published Homola's and Barrett's books.
Following this Update you will find a letter I wrote to the Editor of
TIME Magazine regarding Barrett's statement. I encourage you to do the
same. Stick to the facts, keep your emotions out of it and let them know
that Barrett and his buddies are profoundly ignorant regarding this topic.
The Editorial addresses for Time is: letters@time.com daily@timeinc.net
Send a copy to both and forward a copy to me in case Time does
not publish it and I will post it on the JVSR site.
For those of you who do not respond to Time and who do not
subscribe to JVSR, I encourage you to make a simple contribution to the
research that supports what you do in your practice day in and day out by
subscribing to JVSR.
Otherwise, as one episode after another like this occurs, who will be
the voice that answers them? As always, I look forward to your feedback,
comments and suggestions.