David Singer, D.C., rose to fame in the early 1970s as a featured
speaker at Parker Seminars. He became the youngest chiropractor ever to be
voted "Chiropractor of the Year" by the Parker Foundation, as a
tribute to his willingness to travel all over the United States and Canada
to help fellow chiropractors do better in practice.
Early on, he realized that to get new patients, he had to overcome the
medical and pharmaceutical propaganda that made people fear chiropractic
and believe that only drugs could help them get well. He applied this
knowledge in his own practice and would sign up 50-100 new patients per
week. In just nine months, his practice was logging more than 1,000
patient visits each week. It wasn't long before he had built the largest
new patient practice in the world.
Yet, while Dr. Singer had found the secret to success, he wasn't
willing to let it remain a secret. He wanted to bring it to all D.C.s, so,
in 1981, he founded his consulting company. Since that time, David Singer
Enterprises has been twice named to the prestigious Inc. magazine's
"Top 100 Fastest Growing Companies" list.
Currently on the advisory board of In Practice magazine and The
American Chiropractor, Singer has been in the forefront of the battle
to fight anti-chiropractic prejudice in the medical and insurance
industries. He was one of the largest contributors to the original
anti-trust suit against the American Medical Association and most
recently, he and his clients have made the largest contribution of any
consulting group, toward the new "Save Our Subluxation"
campaign.
In 1999, subscribers of Chiropractic Economics voted Singer the
person who most helped the economics of the chiropractic profession. In
that year alone, his marketing methods brought in over 380,000 new
patients to chiropractors worldwide. His clients have included past and
present presidents of the ICA, ACA, numerous state associations and
chiropractic board members.
The Chiropractic Journal caught up with Singer between trips to
explore the issues facing chiropractic today.
Interview with Dr. Singer
You're famous for having built the world's largest new patient
practice. How did you do that?
I was doing a lot of lectures, going out and meeting people to get them
to be patients but I was becoming completely frustrated in my inability to
get across to the average person what we do and the value of it so they
would, in turn, choose to be a patient.
I was naive enough to think that when you talk to people all you have
to do is make logical sense and that should be enough to make them want to
come and get our care. I was unaware of the fixed, limited, biased
perspective that people have about chiropractic and how strong their
medical drug-oriented viewpoint was.
I couldn't crack through their preconceived notions, until I one day I
figured out there had to be something wrong with what I was doing. I'm not
a bad communicator, so I must have been picking the wrong things to talk
about, or saying them incorrectly or ineffectively to bring about a shift
in how people think.
What I did was analyze the new patients that were coming into my office
and discovered they had four things in common.
One, they actually believed there was something wrong with them.
That step is crucial because many times, chiropractors will speak to
someone who has headaches or back pain and immediately try to explain why
they should come in and get chiropractic. The problem is, the doctors
haven't first found out if the person actually considers what's going on
with his or her body a problem.
Believe it or not, 85% of the population experiences symptoms every
four days, according to Omni magazine. People go around
experiencing headaches, aches and pains, sinus trouble, digestive
disturbances, but they just cope with these problems rather than recognize
them as truly something that can and should be handled.
The point I'm making is that before you can get a new patient, you must
make them shift their perspective and recognize that having symptoms is
not the norm. Unless you can make them undergo that shift, and get them to
admit these symptoms are having a damaging affect on their life (which
takes challenging them in a non-obnoxious way) you'll probably never get
as many new patients as you should.
Second, my new patients all believed chiropractic could help them with
their problem. Chiropractors are notorious for explaining chiropractic
in a way no one can understand unless they've gone to chiropractic school
or been a chiropractic patient for 20 yrs. Telling someone with headaches
that you're going to help them by finding and correcting their
subluxations would make no sense to the average American who has no idea
what a subluxation is or even how the nervous system works to control the
body.
We need to be willing to spend up to 10 minutes explaining how
chiropractic works, in simple analogies, so when we're done talking to
them they understand how their problem is related to their nervous system.
It has to be done in a logical, understandable way so the consumer now
feels that going to a doctor of chiropractic makes sense.
Explaining how chiropractic helps sinus trouble, digestive problems,
hormone problems, or fatigue requires being able to explain the
relationship between the nervous system and stress, and how stress affects
the body and can directly cause those problems and how removing stress on
the nervous system can actually bring about a change in health.
Third, they weren't afraid of chiropractic. To get someone to
become a new patient, you need to overcome their fear that you can
possibly hurt them.
For example, many people are terrified that chiropractic can cause a
stroke. The risk of stroke from chiropractic is so minor, so remote that
it isn't even worth mentioning it, but the medical profession has made it
seem that there's a 50/50 chance of being harmed if you go to a
chiropractor.
The way to deal with the stroke issue is to say, "In chiropractic,
there are 100 techniques ... one of them may hurt people, but we don't use
that technique in our office." That's the end of the story. It's a
lot better than arguing with them that there is no risk with chiropractic.
The dangerous technique is extension of the cervical spine with
rotation. You can also tell the patient, "There are many techniques
in chiropractic; some are very gentle and some are very strong. We can
always use the gentle one if you feel more comfortable with that."
You have to address people's fears and eliminate them or no matter what
you do they'll never become a new patient.
Finally, my new patients all made the decision to do something about
their problems, not continue to just live with them. Too often, you
hear people say they feel they have to learn to live with their symptoms.
For example, I had a patient with terrible sinus condition who had gone to
four medical doctors and been told her problem was caused by a deviated
septum, and she'd have to live with frequent sinus headaches.
I asked her how long she'd had the sinus headaches and she said about
seven years. Then, I asked her how long she'd had the deviated septum and
she said 20 years. I explained that if the deviated septum was causing the
headaches, she would have been having them for 20 years. She started to
think maybe there as something to what I was saying.
Finally, I asked her how often she had the headaches and she said two
or three times a week. When I asked how many days each week her septum was
deviated, she said, of course, it was deviated every day. I pointed out
that the headaches, then, couldn't be coming from the deviated septum.
Something else must be going on. Her deviated septum might be making her
more pre-disposed to sinus headaches, but something else is going on as
well, I explained.
It's knowing how to skillfully, artfully -- and nicely -- educate
people that allows you to change their viewpoint.
Can the average doctor learn to communicate skillfully and artfully?
The good news is that there is only a little bit you need to know to
effectively communicate in order to get new patient. A doctor who is not a
good communicator can become a good communicator by practicing and
rehearsing the dialogue that is essential for the future of their career.
New patients are vital to the actual survival of a practice. Without
them, you can't make it in practice. Doctors who make the decision to be
better communicators only have to simply sit down and rehearse my
procedures with someone they know until they become comfortable and
effective in what they are saying. I can take anyone and, if they were
willing to put in the time and effort, in a matter of hours they'd be
effective in getting new patients. Most important is that they don't have
to become me to do it ... they can be themselves. They can be more
effective in a way that's natural and real to them.
Communication seems more difficult than ever today. Speaking across
generational, cultural and socio-economic lines is a real challenge. Do
these scripts work with everyone?
The basic anatomy of the new patient is the same all over the world. No
matter where they're from or who they are, if they don't think there is
something wrong with them, they're not going to seek out help. If they
don't think what you do can help them, they won't go to you. This dialogue
spans all socio-economic, national and gender lines.
Of course, to be successful in practice, there is more than one piece
to the pie. The first is to get new patients. We teach our clients dozens
of easy and effective, ethical ways to get new patients.
But once they're in the door, you need a way to effectively communicate
the value of what you do so they're willing to spend time and money to
receive your care. They need to be educated about the value of
chiropractic and why it takes time to get results so they will make the
commitment to stay with you. If you simply get new patients but failed to
educate them as to the value of what you do, you'd just have a revolving
door practice.
Time is in short supply for many doctors. Is there something they can
do to make this less time consuming?
Yes. We created a revolutionary system to get C.A.s to do the patient
education and report of findings. If you are going to have a large number
of patients, you have to have a system that can be done by the staff
rather than by the doctor.
To be effective, we divide our patient education program over four
visits, rather than overwhelm new patients with too much material at one
time. We give them information in 15-minute sessions rather than try to
force it down their throat quickly and expect them to decide right away
about whether they want chiropractic.
We believe they first should be educated and understand the value of
chiropractic and the role of the spine and the nervous system before being
asked to make a decision. Chiropractors usually ask people to decide on
the care they should receive before they have enough information to make
the correct decision. Unless they're fully educated, patients will say yes
to the doctor's recommendation just to be polite, but then drop out.
The way we do it, we educate the patients first, then ask them what
they'd like to do. Do they want mere symptom relief or do they want us to
correct the problem that's causing the symptoms in the first place? When
they understand chiropractic and make their own decision, they will stay
as patients.
You've been considered a leader in chiropractic for nearly three
decades. Obviously,
you've seen the profession go through some major changes. What's the
most important issue in the profession right now?
The biggest issue facing chiropractic today -- that most D.C.s are not
aware of -- is the strategic plan of the insurance industry to restrict
reimbursement for chiropractic services. What they're doing is slowly,
over time, slashing chiropractic payments. They look at chiropractic as
little more than fraud. The AMA founded the Council on Quackery and Health
Care Fraud purely to eliminate chiropractic, attack the use of any
alternative cancer therapy, and eliminate vitamins from the market place.
What people are not aware of is that although the AMA lost in the
courts and had to recognize that chiropractic was part of the marketplace,
there remains an enormous prejudice against chiropractic, based on the
false belief that chiropractic is nothing more than health care fraud.
One reason for this is that, in medicine, the majority of health care
costs go for diagnosis rather than treatment. An M.D. will charge a
patient thousands of dollars for all sorts of medical tests and they'll
walk out the door with a single prescription. In chiropractic, patients
spend a small amount for the diagnosis, but a much higher amount for the
actual course of adjustments. In the eyes of the insurance company, that's
fraud. That bias is nothing more than a holdover from the antiquated
prejudice and narrow thinking of the medically dominating insurance
industry that has its roots in the pre-Wilk era.
Do you see that changing in the future?
Right now, in many states, lawsuits are being filed to get insurance
companies to recognize that chiropractic is a legitimate profession and
that our bills should be paid in the same way as medical bills.
Chiropractic is definitely going to win. It's only a question of whether
it's going to be one, two, or three years. Once we win against Blue
Cross/Blue Shield and the courts force them to reimburse us on parity with
any other health care professional for the same type of service, the whole
industry will change.
These lawsuits are being filed with the help of the World Chiropractic
Alliance, the International Chiropractors Association and the American
Chiropractic Association, all working together to protect the right of
chiropractors to adjust subluxations and be paid the same way anyone else
is being paid for the services we provide.
Is there anything the field doctors can do to support those efforts?
They can definitely support the "Save our Subluxation"
campaign being promoted throughout the U.S., by donating as much as they
can to have it written into law that doctors of chiropractic are the only
health care professionals trained and capable of correcting subluxation.
Currently, all HMOs are supposed to provide services for the detection
and correction of subluxation. They have been avoiding chiropractors by
saying they provide chiropractic-like services performed by other
professionals. We know that only chiropractors are trained to correct
subluxations and all chiropractic groups are working to bring about the
inclusion of chiropractic in all federal programs, and make HMOs open up
to chiropractic.
Even with a more positive insurance situation, doctors will face the
challenge of communicating with people, right?
The environment today has made it more difficult than ever to succeed
in chiropractic. Years ago, people got better reimbursement for
chiropractic and there was less competition in the health care field.
Basically, consumers had a choice between medicine and chiropractic. Now,
we have holistic medical doctors, physical therapists who are pushing
legislation to allow patients to go directly to them without referrals,
natural health practitioners, and of course a greater number of D.C.s.
These factors make it more essential than ever for doctors to know how
to communicate with people. In the 1970s, doctors could be lousy
communicators and still do okay. In the '80s, they'd have gotten by. In
the '90s, they'd have been hurting. In this era, they may actually go out
of business.
We see more and more chiropractors leaving the profession today simply
because no one ever taught them how to be effective communicators, how to
get out there and educate people. The mistake doctors make is to think
that, because they went through school, they know everything they need to
know in order to succeed.
The fact is, in order to comply with federal regulations, schools
devote almost all their efforts to scientific and clinical subjects. They
don't have the time to train students to be successful in practice. That's
why consultants like me have actually saved the careers of thousands of
doctors who would never have survived if they hadn't come and learned what
they need know to be successful.
We've talked to many doctors who were already fairly successful when
they went to you, because they wanted to get to the next level. Obviously,
your program isn't only for those doctors on the brink of failure.
Absolutely. Successful doctors know that it's inefficient and
uneconomical to re-invent the wheel. If someone else has already figured
something out, why spend the time and money to figure it out yourself?
Every month we work on finding new programs doctors can bring to their
communities to interact with the population. People have interest in
different subjects, so we create programs geared around specific topics.
If you can learn to educate patients on how you can help with a specific
problem, you can bring more people into your office.
What kind of programs are you talking about?
We have workshops, for instance, that explain natural solutions to
women's health problems. Others include natural solutions for arthritis
pain, how to stretch your way to health, the five secrets to permanent
weight loss, and our most popular topic, the alternative solution to
fibromyalgia pain. Any of these programs, implemented properly, would
greatly expand a doctor's practice.
Our methods work, they've been tested, and are presented like a
cookbook. We offer doctors more ways to expand their practices than they
could ever implement. This way, they can find just the program they feel
comfortable with. They can go home and immediately expand their practice.
There are many fine consultants in the profession. Why do so many
doctors choose your program?
One reason is because we give seminars in eight different cities
throughout the country, to make them accessible to doctors no matter where
they practice. We offer six different weekends in each of these cities
that can train them in 107 different ways to get new patients.
But we don't just hold a seminar and then leave the doctor to work it
out on his or her own. We offer phone consultations to help them
effectively implement the procedures we teach and clients can fax
implementation questions to our unlimited fax hotline service and get an
answer within 48 hours. We also offer seven implementation programs done
over the phone every two weeks to make sure the material we teach gets
used.
There are a number of other important benefits as well, including a fax
newsletter every four to six weeks, a C.A.program, tapes, manuals, boot
camps, advanced skill training sessions, and much more.
Many people say the key element is you, personally. What's your driving
force?
I have over 40 people who work with me. We are a team. We are driven by
a common purpose. My purpose has always been -- and still is -- the
expansion of the chiropractic profession. It is this purpose that has
driven me to travel nearly every week for the last 20 years. I've put in
more time and traveled greater distances on the public speaking circuit
than anyone else in the profession. I do this because it is my belief that
chiropractic possesses the only alternative solution to medicine that can
allow our society to get well the way God meant us to get well -- without
polluting and poisoning our body.
Chiropractic can not only relieve pain and suffering, it can literally
transform the lives of the people we see. It's because of the
overwhelmingly great results that chiropractic can bring that I have
worked my entire life to better enable chiropractors to be more effective
in reaching out and changing the lives of people in their communities.
I personally know the miracles we do. My job is to bring the miracle of
chiropractic to as many people as possible by exploding the success of the
individual chiropractor.