This month, I'll be discussing the latest information on autoimmune
diseases and their impact on women's health worldwide, and highlighting
successful chiropractic case reports involving autoimmune diseases.
Autoimmune diseases, affecting more than 8.5 million Americans, 80% of
them female, are the eighth leading cause of death for women ages 15-64.
Their impact is not limited to the United States, but is a worldwide
issue. Both the United Nations Commission on the Status of Women and the
World Health Organization have been approached to have autoimmune diseases
declared a major women's health concern.
A healthy immune system is designed to protect the body from harm,
responding to both internal or external triggers -- toxins, cancer cells,
substances from another person or species. Disorders in the immune system
can occur when the immune response does not meet the body's needs and may
be too strong, insufficient or not appropriate.
In autoimmune diseases, it is suggested that as the normal control
process is disrupted, the immune system is unable to distinguish between
"self" and "non-self," and reacts by attacking its own
normal tissues. This response can result in the destruction or alteration
in size or function of body tissues and organs, including connective
tissue, muscles, joints, skin, endocrine glands, blood cells and vessels.
There are more than 80 disorders identified, with severity ranging from
uncomfortable to deadly, including: rheumatoid arthritis, multiple
sclerosis, Graves' disease, diabetes, lupus, Hashimoto's thyroiditis,
pernicious anemia and psoriasis. It is suggested that those diagnosed with
an autoimmune disease are at a higher risk for others.
The current approach in medical research is to view these as a related
group of conditions, and identify the elements in common, as evidenced by
a recent article in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA)
on the suggested association between Epstein-Barr and multiple sclerosis.
Gender-based biology
Recent research has included the recognition that women and men have
distinctions not only at a societal level but also at a physiological
level, not limited to differences in hormones. These cellular and
molecular rhythms include differences in perception of pain, energy
storage, metabolism, and responses to initiating agents, which may impact
how health care providers, researchers and the public view and approach
health.
In autoimmune diseases, identified differences between the sexes are:
rates of occurrence (80% women), and chemical make-up of women's immune
system compared to men's i.e., differences in inflammatory response
(less), an enzyme associated with chronic inflammatory disease (higher),
and natural killer cell activity (less).
Sex Hormones also play a role, the most obvious are the changes
observed during pregnancy:
*** Women with rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis can observe
a decrease in symptoms during pregnancy, women with lupus can observe an
increase in symptoms.
*** Two-five percent of all non-diabetic pregnant women develop
gestational diabetes, a form of diabetes that only occurs during pregnancy
and increases the risk for Type II diabetes later in life.
Excluding pregnancy, the influence of sex hormones is considered in:
-- Lupus (systemic lupus erythematosus), which primarily affects women
of childbearing age, and typically decreases in intensity in
postmenopausal women.
-- Multiple sclerosis (MS), where those affected can notice symptoms
worsen in the days preceding menses.
Medical standard of care
There are is medical cure for autoimmune disease. Control of symptoms
is attempted through suppression of the immune system, in hopes of
reducing the attack on the body's own system while leaving some resources
for responding to invaders.
Evidence indicates that results vary, and safety is questionable as the
side effects of immuno-suppressant medications can be toxic. Online, WebMd
reports the great difficulty associated with diagnosis and treatment.
These illnesses are repeatedly misdiagnosed, and they have yet to identify
the cause, hoping that research will have a breakthrough within the next
10 years.
Research into the database of the National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) division of the National Institutes of Health
demonstrates that efforts are being made to explore and document natural
approaches -- including nutritional supplements, elimination of food
allergens, oriental medicine, etc. -- with enough success to stimulate
interest in further and more extensive research.
Chiropractic
Chiropractic's objective is the detection and correction of the
vertebral subluxation, promoting restoration of integrity to the nervous
system, and benefits can include enhanced immune function. Chiropractic's
objective is not a "cure" for any medical diagnosis, but the
behavior of these disorders expresses disorganization, warranting an
evaluation of that which organizes all functions of the body -- the
nervous system -- and determining clinical (rather than medical) necessity
for care.
The malfunction involved in self destruction, i.e. the response does
not meet the body's needs (too strong, insufficient, not appropriate) and
disruption of the normal control process, are familiar indicators of the
impact of subluxations, and I suggest that care/management of these cases
without an appropriate chiropractic evaluation, would be at best,
incomplete.
Let's discuss chiropractic case studies involving autoimmune diseases.
A Journal of Vertebral Subluxation Research (JVSR) case study,
"Upper Cervical Chiropractic Management of a Multiple Sclerosis
Patient: A Case Report" by Dr. Erin Elster, reviews the progress of a
female patient diagnosed with MS three years prior, with progressively
severe symptoms and multiple lesions (MS plaques) evident on an MRI.
Detailed examination revealed evidence of an upper cervical subluxation
and included radiographs, digital infrared imaging and a review of the
patient's history, including a fall that had occurred 10 years prior
(possible causative factor in upper cervical subluxation).
During a two-year course of regular upper cervical care, multiple
reassessments documented the absence of new lesions, continued reduction
in intensity of original lesions and progressive reduction of symptoms
till absent. This success was recorded though post-MRIs, post-thermographic
scans, and neurologist evaluation, all suggesting the intervention of
upper cervical chiropractic care may have stimulated a reversal in the
progression of multiple sclerosis.
In a JVSR case study that I had contributed, during a corporate
screening, a 52- year-old male presented for evaluation due to an
unresolved musculoskeletal concern. He elected to receive chiropractic
care and during a full initial chiropractic evaluation revealed a history
of severe psoriasis, whose symptoms had first appeared after following the
prescribed protocol for taking beta blockers for hypertension.
A Medline search regarding autoimmune diseases reports the
theory that drugs may trigger autoimmune changes, an important factor
considering the severity and chronic nature of these disorders for all
those evaluating medication as part of how they want to impact their body.
Prior to chiropractic care, medical treatment of psoriasis included
immuno-suppressant medication, which reduced the appearance of psoriasis,
yet when treatment was discontinued, a severe and immediate flare-up
occurred, resulting in resumed use of this potentially harmful
intervention.
Results of the chiropractic evaluation confirmed the presence of
subluxation and an appropriate care plan was commenced using a tonal
model, NSA. During the course of care, the patient noticed significant
improvement in reduction of psoriasis symptoms, which was confirmed by his
medical provider and medication was reduced and eventually discontinued.
The patient transitioned successfully to being free of immune-suppressant
medication, without any severe flare-ups.
In addition, as the patient's health continued to restore, he
transitioned to being completely drug free, discontinuing use of
prescription medications for allergies and hypertension.
Other changes demonstrated considerable reduction of indicators of
vertebral subluxation, including range of motion and QOL (improved
response to stress, positive feedback from spouse and colleagues,
increased sense of ease and better posture).
I encourage chiropractors to include this information when reaching out
to their community through screenings, health talks, and in initial exams,
to increase awareness of the impact of subluxation on the immune system
and the concerns women are faced with.
Chiropractic's immense popularity and success with health care
consumers has yet to be reflected and honored by research and grant
institutions, but it is one of my goals to help create that shift, and to
do further research on the association between enhanced immune function
and the response to chiropractic care.
Please feel free to contact me with additional cases involving improved
immune function, and also if you would like any references or sources from
this column, as they were too numerous to mention here.
Also, the WCA Council on Women's Health looks forward to seeing all of
you at the World Chiropractic Alliance Summit in April (call 800/347-1011
to register)!
Feel free to contact me at mbdcawe@aol.com, or Veroncia Gutierrez at
veronicapgdc@aol.com.
(Madeline Behrendt, D.C., vice-chair of the World Chiropractic Alliance
Council on Women's Health, is author of "A Woman's Experience/A.W.E.,"
a practice manual offering a subluxation-based perspective on diverse
aspects of women's health. Dr. Behrendt's articles have appeared in
numerous print and electronic publications, and she has completed a
research paper for the Journal of Vertebral Subluxation Research.)