The
World Chiropractic Alliance also responded to the article, "Is This
Your Spinal Answer" in the December 2001 issue of Men's Health,
which contained numerous negative comments on chiropractic. To read the
response from the WCA, as well as from Matthew McCoy, editor of the
Journal of Vertebral Subluxation Research, visit the WCA website at www.worldchiropracticalliance.org.
Once again, the World Chiropractic Alliance (WCA) was called upon to
rebut an anti-chiropractic article circulating on the internet. The
article, called "Chiropractic and Asthma," was posted on the
"asthma" section of the About.com website (asthma.about.com/library/weekly/aa071999.htm)
The "About.com" is a network of more than 700
"Guide" sites covering some 50,000 subjects. Each Guide site is
run by an individual with either particular expertise or experience in his
or her guide topic. Guide sites also normally contain links to various
other websites on the subject.
The article, although not bylined, repeated the now-familiar rhetoric
of chiropractic critics such as Stephen Barrett, well as links to articles
by Barrett and to the ChiroBase site which he operates with William
Jarvis.
The link for the "Chiropractic and Asthma," appears on the
Guide site's "Quake Cures" page, with a teaser reading:
"Don't be fooled by the smoke and mirrors, it's no match for real
science."
The article repeats well-worn misinformation about chiropractic, and
dismisses chiropractic research by saying: "... chiropractic,
'studies' paid for and carried out by chiropractic associations find
plenty of subjective information supporting their claims. As with many
quack asthma cures and treatments, the basis of their findings are
anecdotal, testimonial, and lack real scientific controlled studies to
support some amazing claims."
The Asthma guide is run by John N. Rhoades, a Registered Respiratory
Therapist who claims to have "treated and taught hundreds of
asthmatic patients."
When informed of the presence of this article on the About Guide, the
World Chiropractic Alliance immediately contacted Rhoades, explaining the
true meaning and purpose of chiropractic to him and providing him with a
number of research studies showing that subluxation correction can have a
beneficial affect on the health of asthmatic patients.
As of press time, the WCA has not received a response from Rhoades on
this issue. "We will give him a reasonable amount of time to correct
this situation by removing the article," stated Terry A. Rondberg,
D.C., president of the WCA. "If he does not do so, we will contact
the management of About.com and request that they re-evaluate their
selection of Rhoades to fill this position as a Guide host."
The WCA asks all doctors to contact Rhoades (asthma.guide@about.com)
with their opposition to the articles and, if necessary, to follow up with
a complaint to about.com.