November
2002
I am responsible
by Dr. Matthew McCoy, editor, Journal of Vertebral Subluxation
Research
How many times have you heard chiropractors get up in front of a room
and start talking about all the people they've helped, all the people
chiropractic helps every day, all the people they've healed of this or
that disease, etc?
Having grown up in chiropractic circles, I've had the opportunity to
hear lots of "old timers" speak on the subject of chiropractic,
chiropractic miracles, subluxation, politics etc.
I love to listen to these pioneers talk, whether it's one-on-one or
before a large group. They have such a rich history and deep wisdom to
pass on to the future generations of young chiropractors who will carry on
their work.
Your
profession needs you
"It is becoming increasingly clear that a flawed or misinterpreted
clinical trial is of less value than an accurate and clearly written case
report." -- Anthony Rosner, Ph.D., FCER Director of Research
The Journal of Vertebral Subluxation Research (www.jvsr.com) wants
your Case Studies. The profession of chiropractic, and subluxation-based
chiropractic in particular, needs your Case Studies. A Case Study is
simply a detailed description of what happened between you and your
patient. JVSR has several ways to assist you in completing a Case Study
including Tutorials and one on one coaching. For more information, visit
www.jvsr.com, or contact Dr. Matthew McCoy, JVSR Editor at editor@jvsr.com.
I've also had the opportunity to hear lots of young, inspired
chiropractors with large practices talk about the hundreds or thousands of
people they see every week and all the miracles they see day in and day
out. I also love to listen to them since it encourages me and is a
reminder of the power and potential of the adjustment.
The problem with all this is that it's all anecdotal — and anecdotes
are just above folklore and just below the Case Study in the hierarchy of
research.
I don't care how many files and how many x-rays you have of patients
who have been healed of every disease in the Merck Manual, if it isn't
written up and published in a peer reviewed journal, our profession and
future patients are deprived of the benefits of your experience.
The inspiring talk becomes just that: talk. True, it may inspire,
motivate and infuse you with the courage to confront your patients and
overcome the hurdles of patient education and compliance.
But wouldn't it be nicer if you didn't need to spend all the energy you
do trying to get "pumped up" by the latest chiropractic savior?
What if people knew they needed to see you? Does the average
person know what cancer is? Of course not. They don't have a clue as to
the details of its histological characteristics, epidemiology and nature.
But the average person knows about the need to get screened for it and
seek care if the tests come back positive.
My point is not to get into the nuances and controversy of the multi
billion-dollar cancer industry. My point is this — why doesn't society
have the same appreciation for chiropractors and the service we provide?
Why do we still only see 10-15% of the population? Where the heck is the
hundredth monkey? (Editor's note: if you're unfamiliar with the concept
of the "hundredth monkey," see the accompanying sidebar.)
Consider the following shocking statistics:
 | The entire chiropractic profession has only 70
full-time researchers |
 | The drug company Pfizer has 12,000 full time
researchers |
 | Less than 5% of full-time D.C. faculty at
chiropractic institutions are involved in research |
 | The total budgeting for all chiropractic institutions
is a mere $224 million. Of that $224 million our institutions spend
only $4 million on research programs |
 | Harvard University receives $739 million a year from
the NIH alone just to do research. |
 | In the entire 100+ year history of the chiropractic
profession we have received less than $10 million from the federal
government for research |
 | The top 25 medical schools received $6 billion
dollars from the NIH in 2000 alone |
 | Less than 10% of our profession subscribes to a peer
reviewed chiropractic research journal. |
I maintain that the hundredth monkey is waiting to see the facts before
he washes his fruit and we have simply failed to provide those facts. Even
if some faction of the profession wanted to say they were more scientific
than some other group, the above facts still stare back at all of us. This
is a profession wide problem in need of a profession wide solution and the
first step is for each one of us to say: "I am responsible."
Practitioners must engage themselves in the process. Too many graduate
from chiropractic college, step into practice and leave behind any memory
of scholarly activity. Each member of this profession needs to commit to
participating in several research oriented activities every year. This
could be simply subscribing to a peer reviewed chiropractic journal,
donating money to a chiropractic research association and attending a
scientific symposium.
Those practitioners who have been fortunate enough to amass a small
fortune must step forward and put some of that money to use in
chiropractic research. Build a building and put your name on it if that's
what it takes. The next time you hear a chiropractic guru tell you how
many thousands of patient visits he sees every week, ask him how much of
the money he's raking in has been donated for chiropractic research.
The next time you hear chiropractors brag about all the people they've
gotten out of wheelchairs, ask them why they haven't written those cases
up, subjected them to peer-review and attempted publication.
When they says they just don't have the time because they're seeing
2,000 patients a week, ask why they haven't hired somebody to do it for
them. There are lots of underpaid, under appreciated faculty at
chiropractic colleges who would love to help.
Every practitioner must commit to taking an interesting case from his
or her office and compiling a case study and submitting it to a peer
reviewed chiropractic journal.
I know plenty of chiropractors who will stay up all night writing a
narrative to collect $2,000 on a PIP claim but cringe at the idea of
writing a simple case study. Others who are more inclined need to engage
in more advanced forms of practice based research. The next time you
wonder why that HMO won't let you on their plan, or why the government
doesn't recognize us, or why that last new patient never came back, or why
the state board is attacking your technique – take a look in the mirror
and say these words: "I am responsible."
(Matthew McCoy, D.C., is presently Editor of the Journal of Vertebral
Subluxation Research (www.jvsr.com), and an Instructor at Life University
College of Chiropractic. He has practiced in both the United States and
Russia since graduating from Life in 1989. Dr. McCoy has pursued extensive
Post Graduate training and maintains active involvement in several
chiropractic political and research organizations including: The Council
on Chiropractic Practice, World Chiropractic Alliance, The Chiropractic
Advocacy Council, International Chiropractor's Association, Council on
Applied Chiropractic Science, Council on Chiropractic Clinical Science,
Georgia Council of Chiropractic, Academy of Upper Cervical Chiropractic
Organizations and The International Spinal Health Institute. He is also a
member of the Post Graduate Faculty of Life University College of
Chiropractic. A sought-after speaker and expert witness, he can be reached
at editor@jvsr.com).