January 2006

Going to jail

by Dr. Christopher Kent

Many chiropractors today face challenges in their quest to realize the vision of worldwide leadership of health care with the chiropractic model. These include attempts to limit the availability of chiropractic care to any person who wishes to receive it. Such challenges range from economic disincentives by third‑party payers, to regulatory abuses, and the promulgation of questionable practice parameters.

Yet, the challenges we face today pale compared to those which confronted chiropractors who went before us. As we begin a new year, it is fitting to remember those courageous chiropractors that went to jail rather than abandon their goals and moral values.

The first chiropractor to be incarcerated for practicing medicine without a license was the discoverer, D.D. Palmer. A 1906 newspaper article [1] chronicles an interview with D.D. at the Scott County Jail, where he was confined in a cell 8x11 feet. The Court offered him the alternative of paying a fine. D.D. chose jail, stating, "After I went to jail, several parties phoned to my home and others called offering to lend me money with which to pay my fine. I am not in cell for lack of princiPAL but for an abundance of princiPLE."

The resolve of the discoverer becomes clear when the interviewer writes, "Dr. Palmer states he is treated well by all the jail officials and has no complaint to make. 'Only one thing I would like to do which they will not allow me,' stated the doctor, 'is to hang out my sign over the window to my cell.'"

Other early chiropractors did not fare as well while serving time, and the sentences were sometimes harsh. Callender noted that, "In 1923, B.F. Lear and W.E. Quartier were fined $500 or 833 days in jail, the maximum sentence for a first offense. They chose the Trumbull county jail in Warren, Ohio." [2] If you do the math, that's more than two years.

Jail life could be severe. Another chiropractor, W.D. Adrian, was sentenced to 500 days. Portions of a letter from Morgan County Jail reads, "...We see an occasional rat, but all the bugs apparently were killed last summer in a big raid on the jail. I could stand some springs or a mattress on the bars I sleep on, but outside of this and the disagreeable dispositions of some of the prisoners, I am getting along nicely." [3]

The 1923 Palmer Lyceum was dedicated to those who served jail time for chiropractic. Callender quotes Mac Searby, "It takes a real man, a real woman to go to jail. Some are parted from their families; little baby fingers and arms and lips are far away when bedtime comes. Mother is worrying. Sunshine is nowhere behind the bars except in the hearts of these boys and girls, and the least of their worries is that their business is all shot to pieces. They have cut themselves off from every tie, every support that the free man has, and they have gone back to the cells again when the test came a second time." [2]

It is not always easy to behave heroically. It is far easier to blend in with the status quo ‑‑ to not rock the boat ‑‑ to trade short‑term expediency for a greater vision. Herbert Ross Reaver, DC, recognized as the profession's most jailed chiropractor, wrote, "It was a matter of principle for all of us. We don't practice medicine in any shape or form. To be designated as limited medical practitioners was something intolerable to us. And, of course, it was a useless thing anyway because the so‑called permit limited the types of cases we could handle. It was just something that any chiropractor with any guts could not accept. [4]

Some paid the ultimate price. Consider the following obituary: "Dr. Albert Ivnik, chiropractor, Cleveland, Ohio, died yesterday at seven P.M. He never recovered from the effects of the exposure at Warrensville Workhouse, and has been in bed from time to time since resuming his practice in February, and finally passed away last night. He leaves a wife and...four children." [5]

In accepting the 2004 Lee‑Homewood Award, Russell Gibbons said, "The right to health‑care freedom somehow took its place along with those movements that had characterized the story of progressive reform in America. Jailing of chiropractors and the struggle that this represented would become part of the process of building a better nation by the abolitionists, the suffragettes, the labor movement, the civil rights struggle‑‑all of which would have a larger meaning and understanding after that simple act of defiance outside a county jail. [6]

Consider what impact one courageous person can accomplish. When Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat to a white man on a bus in 1955, she changed the course of history. How easy it would have been for her to be a "good Negro" who "fit in" and accepted things as they'd been done in the past, regardless of how insulting, and without consideration for the future.

Thankfully, we are not asked to give our lives for chiropractic. As guardians of our 'sacred trust," we are, however, expected to act heroically in defending the profession, and those it serves.

References

1. "Dr. D.D. Palmer talks in jail." Davenport Democrat 4/2/06.

2. Callender A: "Buckeye chiropractic: turbulence in a limited branch of medicine, 1915‑1975." Chiropractic History 1995;15(2):79‑89.

3. Fountain Head News 1923;13(7):6. Quoted in Callender (2).

4. Bower N, Hynes R Jr: "Going to jail for chiropractic: a career's defining moment." Chiropractic History 2004;24(2):21‑26.

5. Fountain Head News 1923;12(46):1. Quoted in Callender (2).

6. Gibbons RW: Acceptance of the Lee‑Homewood Award: remarks, 22 May 2004. Chiropractic History 2004;24(2):17‑18.

(Dr. Christopher Kent, president of the Council on Chiropractic Practice, is a 1973 graduate of Palmer College of Chiropractic. The WCA's "Chiropractic Researcher of the Year" in 1994, and recipient of that honor from the ICA in 1991, he was also named ICA "Chiropractor of the Year" in 1998. He is director of research and a co‑founder of Chiropractic Leadership Alliance. With Dr. Patrick Gentempo, Jr., Dr. Kent produces a monthly audio series, "On Purpose," covering current events in science, politics and philosophy of vital interest to the practicing chiropractor. For subscription information call 800/892‑6463.)